Benjamin Michael once asked me, "Michael, is there going to be a top ten list this year?" Not a split second passed when I cried out, "Hell, yes!", then realized I was in Church. I blamed Tourette's because, hey, my special-circumstances gift card expires if I don't use it at least once a year. I kid.
2008 started out lookin' pretty good. While my eyes were fixed squarely on that summer release of Sigur Rós' latest, my ears' interest piqued when rumors of an M.Ward/Zooey Deschanel collaboration loomed. What's that I see? A new Death Cab! I'm sorry, did you say
Copeland has a new one coming out? No, way. All in all, things were shaping up well enough.
Then the disappointment crept in. The Death Cab For Cutie was good, but not crucial. Elvis Costello, I love you, but apparently not enough. Actually, it wasn't you at all- i blame the keyboards. And Coldplay! Coldplay! COOOOOOLDPLAAAAAAAY!!!! Three out of ten? I liked so
three out of ten?
Viva just wasn't the crescendo I had looked forward to, but then again, neither was X & Y. I should have known.
There were plenty of diamonds in the proverbial rough- even a few that wanted to stay coal, as Tom Waits put it- and those worthy good eggs will listed in orderly fashion below. Since I've become keenly aware of the pop bandwagon, I'm going to try to reflect music I actually listened to this year instead of that which is super cool these days. Invariably, the two camps will cross lines, so I hope not to come off as an elitist, my-music-is-WAY-more-obscure-than-yours. In all actuality, there's little obscurity in most of my picks this year. Go find 'em!
13. Thrice, The Alchemy Index Vol. III & IV, Air & Earth
Yeah, there's gonna be 13? Why? Because I live in America, where the credo of such an enlightened people is, "Everyone has the right to sue and everyone gets a trophy!" Yay!
But really, if I were a farrier of fine novelty awards, I would first-class one straight to the door of Dustin Kensrue & Co with a plaque reading, "Most Changed, 1998-2008". They've come a long way, baby.
I have to say, I loved Thrice the first time I heard them in 2002. A friend from a band shoved
The Illusion of Safety in my CD deck and I was floored. So much angst, such great guitar riffs! How could it get better?
Looking back through this band's career, the meandering route they've hewn through musical genres makes perfect sense. They've gone from their punk/metal/hardcore roots and re-invented their sound numerous times, from country to digital and now, to a softer brand of rock.
Volumes I & II, Fire & Water, packaged together like this latest installment, took cues from their previous,
Vhiessu, but showed us a band becoming more and more versatile. They've honed their craft, and though they've still got all of the requisite thrice elements in play, there, peering over the edge of maturity, are digital drums, synths, atmospherics that just make sense. On
Air & Earth, we see even more brilliance in melody, harmony, instrumentation and a total mastery of the loud/quite dynamic so utterly lost on today's self-described 'heavy' artists. (I'm looking at you, Underoath! You know there's a clean channel, right?!) And what's better is they pull all of this off, and have done so consistently, without ever sounding whiny, deprived, and screamo-centric as most of their contemporaries. Dustin's vocals are better than ever, easily putting him in the same pretty/ugly school as Billy Corgan, minus the carnivality of it all.This is a huge sounding record, and though it's in volumes it really is one big conceptual effort. Each final song of these discs are in different keys, but deals with the same lyrical themes of man's relationship to the prescribed element, using the same melodic and chordal ideas. If you're looking for something that has some seriously inventive songwriting, thoughtful lyrics wrought with biblical and telluric imagery and feels honest, just go get all four volumes.
12. She & Him, Volume OneEver see
Elf? That blonde-ish chick with the deep, entrancing voice? Or
Winter Passing, the Will-Ferrell vehicle that wasn't like the rest that starred that brunette? Okay, okay, but what about the short-lived Sci-Fi Channel re-imagining of L. Frank Baum's
Wizard of Oz ,
Tin Man? Or the only good thing about Matthew McConaughey's
Failure to Launch? That would be She.
Ever bought Nora Jones'
Not Too Late, and listened to the background vocals and guitar on "Sinkin' Soon? Like Bright Eyes' recent stuff? Him is all over that.
1940's and '50's influenced M. Ward (check out his last release,
Post-War, you'll thank yourself) and actress Zooey Deschanel teamed up in 2008 to bring us one of the most sweet and surprising releases since
Once won an Oscar. Still hingeing on themes of love and contentment, as well as being hopelessly, sentimentally ruined by someone, there's still a good bit more innocence on this release than on any of the music released by the ginger one and his Czech arm candy. Less of a heartbroken, defeated memoir and more like how Sandy Dumbrowski and Danny Zuko would sound today, minus the car racing and, ugh, Rizzo. There's hope here, and it's relentlessly fun as new love should be. With moments of mouth-only imitations of horn parts, Zooey's forlorn-country-gal vocals, and M. Ward's echoey, sometimes Hawaiian, historic signature sound, this record easily outshines many of the year's others. Really, it's one of my favourites. Mostly uptempo (but never a low point) and shamelessly reminiscent of the best 50's love songs, this record is just brilliant. It's hard to imagine Ms. Deschanel being more desirable than she already is, with that deadpan wit and fair skin. But, welp, there you go.
Congrats to Zooey for becoming engaged to Death Cab's Ben Gibbard!
My deepest condolences to Death Cab's remaining members for the imminent, somewhat tragic loss of their lead singer.
11. Retribution Gospel Choir, Retribution Gospel ChoirAt times reminding me of Low and Pedro the Lion, and some of the best rock from better days, RGC has a hunger and ferocity in their mid-tempo compositions that really puts me at ease. I could listen to this all day. But I don't because, of This Will Destroy You, who sadly haven't put out anything in 2008, but deserve mention anyway.
Though there's rarely a moment in this disc that breaks the Guitar-Bass-Drums-Vocals formula, the brainchild of Low singer Alan Sparhawk (interesting that it reminded me of Low, eh?) is described on the
Caldo Verde site like this: "
Low visionary Alan Sparhawk cranks the amps for a radical stylistic departure. Crude, mangy guitars collide with trudging stoner-rock rhythms and some catchy melodies -- for modern-day spirituals that defy all preconceptions"
It's low-fi all the way, in the same sort of tradition of early Guided By Voices, Sebadoh, Pavement and The Mountain Goats. Anymore, I tire easily of bands who put anything but the song first, and RGC definitely, decidedly makes song structure King, although it's a less ornate title than with other groups. Simplicity reigns, but they are finished-feeling songs. There's nothing lacking, and it perfectly fills the void left by Low and Mogwai and the heavier moments of Starflyer 59. It's a void that needs filling.
10. The Weepies, HideawayAs much as I enjoy this record, there's not a lot I can say for it. It's not a huge change in
cover art, that's for sure. It's not necessarily brand-new sounding, though there's a slickness and freshness to some of the production that's been lacking to previous efforts. The songs are catchy as H, but hey, they've always been, right?
I guess what I'm telling you could be taken as damning, but that's not the case here. It's more of the same, which with the Weepies, it's not a bad thing at all. I really enjoy this band. I find myself stuck on a melody not remembering where I'd picked it up, like gum on the sole. Only this gum is clean, and it's still good. I chew it and chew it, still unsure of its origin but enjoying it purely. All of a sudden, it hits me- and I know it comes from a source of good repute. Seriously, just about every song hooks you like a
Sea Kitten. (i meant to write about that a long time ago. Just visit the link and you'll know. Jessica Simpson's gonna be so confused! Oh, and read the story books. Seriously. You guys. Seriously.) Really addictive, folky, poppy, easy music. Hey, these guys made Mandy Moore sound good (she usually just looks good) on Wild Hope, so give 'em a chance. And, much like another die-hard favourite of mine
The National, who were
#2 on last year's fine list, they've been featured in Barack Obama's Campaign.
Take a listen to "All Good Things", "Can't Go Back Now", "Just Blue", and "Orbiting" and you'll see why these guys could kick all of the a**es of all of the Sixpence None The Richers and any other generic folk-poppers you can name.
9. Ray La Montagne, Gossip In The GrainIn an year full of folk for folk's sake, Ray-with-the-nigh-unpronounceable-last-name (does anyone else feel like they're wrong every time, no matter how you say it?) humbly holds out at arm's length one of the great treasures of the year . It's so good, I gleefully ran straight home from the record store, clutching this disc in my throbbing arms all Charlie Bucket-style, then threw it in a bowl and poured milk over it in order to fully digest it's grainy, wheaty goodness.
Here you'll find deep folk trappings, 1960's good rockin', R&B cues, and that buttery/syrupy, heartbreaking voice that goes just as well with pancakes and toast as an iPod. Where She & Him expresses the heights of new love with excitement, Ray's
Gossip is a serious, steadfast take on the subject. It's a record that says to the listener, "You and I are on a journey, and I'm in it for the long haul, baby." It's a picture-perfect rendition of commitment through hard times, with lyrical passages like that in "Let It Be Me".
"Feels like you always coming up last/Pockets full of nothin' and you got no cash/No matter where you turn you ain't got no place to stand/ Reach out for something and they slap your hand/ Now i remember it all too well/ just how it feels to be all alone/ You feel like you'd give anything/ For just a little place you can call your own/ That's when you need someone, someone that you can call/ and when all your faith is gone/ Feels like you can't go on/ Let it be me" This is serious stuff, folks. He's an incredible creative force to be reckoned with. I can't decide... this one or
Till the Sun Turns Black? Let's not decide.
L... La... La MonTANE.
08. Russian Red, I Love Your GlassesThis is one of Debbie's favourites this year. She told me I'd love it, and where others have claimed that very thing and scared the bejeezus out of me, she is completely trustworthy. Was she right? It's in the list, isn't it?
Lourdes Hernandez, who hails from Madrid, Spain, knits together some of the most intimate little folk songs you're likely to hear. Shimmering voice and quaint instrumentation go a long way in this release, making for just pretty, pretty music. She's a diminutive girl, with a chirpy voice and the most alluring of accents. Words like 'situation' and 'smoked' and 'outside' get special treatment, which is more than okay with me. I'm even impressed with her cover of Cyndi Lauper's "Girls Just Wanna Have Fun"!
07. Lykke Li, Youth Novels
The album's first track, "Melodies & Desires" starts off in hardly less than epic terms. Spoken-word instructions set the mood for the Swedish pop star's debut, and sets it in a big way. Like so many other records on this list, themes are love-based, but this one forgoes the foreplay, and dives straight into a more sensual take.
"Love is the harmony/Desire is the key/ Love is a symphony/ Now play it with me/ You be the rhythm and I'll be the beat/ You be the rhythm and I'll be the beat/ Then I'll be the rhythm and you'll be the beat/ and love, the shoreline, where you and I meet"
Later gems include "And for you I keep my legs apart/ and forget about my tainted heart/ and I will never be the first to say it but still I, yes you know I... I... I..." But even with the sensuality, it lacks the smarmy glow so quickly added to the sum total of American pop stars' releases. Yes, there is a sexual element, but it's in no way as tasteless as the latest Pussycat Dolls' or Spears' track. And it's in the context of some truly interesting music. You can certainly distinguish the influence of Bjorn of Peter Bjorn and John. Some might not enjoy it, but I do. On a drive to visit Meredith in Philly early in December, I popped this in as i was just entering the city and was astounded by how perfect a fit the two were. It's a fun, memorable record that you can't help but appreciate, if only for the play between innocence and deviousness.
06. Dr. Dog, Fate
How fitting, then, that the next consecutive record actually
came from Philly? Dr. Dog draws comparisons to 1960's groups like The Band, and rightly so. They sit firmly in that space and own it. Although there's not a bevy of information available about the band, it seems that they all have, or at least
had, real jobs including one member being a certified lawyer. Touring with the likes of The Raconteurs and Clap Your Hands Say Yeah can't help that much, though. Nor can putting out a solid slice of Americana. Fate is good to the last drop, psychedelia intact. It is worth every minute of your time.
Tracks of note include "Hang On", "The Old Days", "The Ark" and "From".
And where does one find the blankets that all these album covers exist upon? There's nothing I'd love more than to wrap myself up with these inexplicable images, curling up in some Bright Eyes and Fate, which is Nice and Nicely Done, sitting hot cocoa on Denison Witmer's hand-towel-cum-coaster. Snuggled under my Do Make Say Think and Cinder paintings, the wall paper catches my eye and I think to myself, "Let's Get Out of This Country". Just outside the window, looking past the Ohio tree, I can see mountains of Lekman- far beyond Occupanther forest- and it's about to turn Melody A.M. I drift off now, my mind retracing the Stars at Noon, while Rain Dogs play and snarl. As I finally get ...A Better View of the Rising Moon, I regret that don't have any Umbrellas, as I'm likely to catch Pneumonia. Or some sort of Wesley Willis Fiasco.
Lord, I'm tired. Did you catch any of that? Bonus points if you did.
05. Ryan Adams & The Cardinals, Cardinology
I'm a huge fan of this guy. He's prolific as songwriters come, and he's a killer musician to boot. Problem is, he's got no filter. He puts out an album at least every year, sometimes 3, but sometimes there's only a handful of tracks on each that are really impressive. You get the feeling that he'd be better off just releasing one or two every few years. His last record,
Easy Tiger, for example, didn't really stand out at all to me, which as a fan, saddens me. I wasn't sure what to expect with this one.
Lucky me, then, to have had all of my fears assuaged. It's brilliant! A masterpiece! Every song, every one, is great. From the first acoustic guitar line to the last piano refrain is singable, memorable, lovable. Songs like "Go Easy" and "Magick" showcase Ryan's country rock roots, while "Fix It" and "Let Us Down Easy" give us a glimpse of the soul that lurks deep within. "Cobwebs" is just huge, while "Crossed-Out Name" is subdued. It's a great sounding record, rife with Fender amps and Fender and Gibson instruments going for absolutely vintage tones. Heck, the guy was a huge part of my last decision over what
guitar to go for.The only song I would leave or take would be "Natural Ghost", and that's only because my withered ears still can't quite fall for the chorus line. Sounds squished. Still, good song, even though it's not my fave.
It's true; this one surprised me, and it was only the most pleasant of surprises. I love it. It's one of the few CDs that stay in the case it came in, kind of an elite group of things I like to listen to
and look at. If loved songs like "La Cienga Just Smiled", "Cry On Demand", "When the Stars Go Blue", even songs from the Whiskeytown days, you owe it to yourself to pick this one up.

04. Colm Mac Con Iomaire, The Hare's Corner
This is the first solo release from the violinist of Irish band The Frames and also The Swell Season which both include Glen Hansard of the film Once. Though he tours relentlessly with both acts, Colm is very much a talented musician and composer in his own right. From multi-instrumental songs to a few with Colm looping violin over violin, live, this record has more to it than meets the eye.
Colm himself explained the title of this year's best instrumental album, which I will paraphrase. A hare's corner was a spot on a large piece of farm land left as a refuge for the rabbits to run to when equipment came out and farmers got tired of having crops destroyed. They would leave a little patch untouched, vegetation free for the taking and land left for burrowing. It was almost an unspoken agreement between the farmers and they; "If you stay out of my way, I'll stay out of yours" sums it up.
What does this mean for Colm's release? His album, though purely instrumental, has much to do with preserving heritage, and more specifically, his language. You see, Gaelic, like many other languages, is in danger of fading away completely because of the widespread acceptance of English. In Ireland, there are still strongholds known as 'Gaeltachtaí', meaning 'Irish speaking regions' that have mostly been spared from the harvester's sicle. Still, danger still looms.
Another meaning to the metaphor comes directly from Colm's Hare's Corner Site:
"The Hare has long been associated in Ireland with the Superstitious and the Supernatural and was considered to be the 'Shape-Shifter', the traveller between worlds.
I was captivated by the metaphor of the "Hare's Corner"..
It represents for me the wild and mysterious source of the many rivers of music and imagination..
The music here on this record are the strange gifts I returned with from my many walks in the long grass!"
That says it all. I encourage you to seek out this music and really, buy it. Not only is it a great listen, Colm is really one of the most stand-up guys I've ever had the pleasure of meeting. Much more stand-up than an other certain Irishman.
Click the link above for his awesome dual-language site.
03. Fleet Foxes, Fleet FoxesThis has been the year of dual album covers. It seems that a few of my favourites from this year have come in two forms: the widely-released version and the hey-where-did-that-come-from version with the cover only I have. I'm confused not only because there are two different covers, of which i prefer the simpler, colored box version, but because there happens to be a different title associated with the one I like. Strangely enough, there exist all of the same tracks on either version, so either my iTunes has crapped on itself, or I'm just that cool.
No matter which cover you prefer, this one is for

keeps. The vocal harmonies are stright out of
How to Sound Like The Beach Boys book 1 and they do the job well. They take it further from the car and girl obsessed days of yore, instead writing about squirrels, snow, tigers, strawberries, and my name. Really, you could call this one close to Animal Collective, the Zombies, and others in the vein, but these guys stand out as something uniquely entertaining, and eminently listenable.
02. Delta Spirit, Ode To Sunshine
Benjamin Michael told me, "It's like drinking songs. You'll love it." He is another that I trust, so I gave it a spin, but only after I worked up the nerve. See, that description, though accurate, didn't prepare me for how good this really was going to be. I thought, 'oh, it's just a bunch of drunks singing.' What Ben meant is that you grab a lager, and you listen. Piano and guitars surround the hooks in these songs like the kid with the most lunch money. I couldn't help but be taken back to early Ben Folds, but there's more group fun here. Lots of gang vocals, lots of spindly little nuances to be had.
And again, it really does feel like songs to drink to. Not to forget, but to remember. Imagine at a big family gathering, you all start telling stories, and your dad gets up, sits at the piano, and starts singing songs connected to that time you fell off the swing set, and your Aunt Mildred fell off the wagon... again. Think the opening sequence of "All in the Family", but without the racism.
I LOVE THIS RECORD. It's fun, it's singable, the back-beats make it danceable, and it's better if you put your arms around those to your right and left. Ugh. Spill your drink, then get this.
01. Sigur Rós, Með suð í eyrum við spilum endalaustYou knew it. It had to be this band. Of all of the bands it could've been, this was the only one that takes the coveted #1 spot. Why? Because they're one of the few bands that make art anymore. Sure, there's a ton of bands who throw guitars down stairs and call it art, but when it comes down to it, how much can you listen to it?
That's where Iceland's favorite band comes in. (for realsies, in a survey, Icelanders identify with this band more than any other. Sigur Rós has become a source of national pride.)
Their sound has been called all kinds of things- enigmatic, atmospheric, etherial, cinematic, epic (me, various times)- and still, others scratch their heads at the boys' lengthy compositions, many of which are sung in a made-up language known as Hopelandic. Yes, most of the time it's just the same sounds repeated over the course of a whole song, but I happen to adore it. Georg Holm, the band's bassist, once told an interviewer that it's "interactive music", meaning that they aren't trying to directly say anything with their music- the point is for the listener to get out of it what they will.
Many people first hear Sigur Rós and ask two questions, the first being "Is that a girl singing?", the other being "Really? That's a guy?" Jonsi sings in a pained falsetto that's only added to the mystery of their creations, and balances perfectly with his guitar technique. What technique? The technique of using a Cello bow to play the electric guitar. The sound can be described as a "cello on steroids" (me, all the time) and is huge. Like a moan or a wail that keeps going, the droning notes he plays mix perfectly with the low-toned bass and pulsing drums, the wiry keyboards.
They use all kinds of other instruments to craft their songs, including marimba, guitar, many, many drums, pianos, the all femal string quartet that travels with them, Amiina, and various toys to add to the mood. At times, they use an entire marching band.
Each of their records mark great strides in developing their sound, and you get the feeling that the band really does intend to make the greatest music they can. Each record has gotten bigger and better, and this last one is no exception.
Almost altogether, they leave behind the bowed guitar and instead focus on Grandpa's Guitars- there's lots of acoustic instruments here, and what's that? Real words? Lyrics for this record were written in both Icelandic and English, marking the first time that any of the West-Germanic tongue creeping into their compositions. Even though it's hard to decipher, the words on the album's final track, "All Alright" fit perfectly. But what does it all mean?

Með suð í eyrum við spilum endalaust means, roughly, "With a buzz in our ears, we play endlessly" evoking a love of the craft that's sometimes hard to find in today's commercial music. Music really is their mission, and from the first beats of track 1, Gobbledigook, they hit the mark. Gobbledigook marks what will end up being their happiest record to date. Tribal and heartbeat stabilizing, it's hard to listen without feeling like you're part of some secret club of people who enjoy life, dancing, and simply being. Check out their
performance of the song with Bjork at Nattura to get a feel for just how mob-like this song can get. With two strings on his guitar, and at least 4 times as many drums involved, it's hard not to clap, get happy, and sing along with what little you can understand. It's FUN.The album looses no steam from track 2 (Inní mér syngur vitleysingur, in case you were wondering) on, with that one containing one of the most uplifting bridge sections I've ever heard. It all leads up to an explosive, joyful outpouring and leaves warm fuzzies in the stomach of all around. Things stay pretty throughout, but a personal favourite is the 6th song, Með suð í eyrum. Piano ornamentation ranging from simple to complex provide the basis of a truly beautiful song. You don't need to know what the words mean to get it. As big a language problem could exist here, the chills that come at the eruptive finale make things as overt as they need to be.
This has got to be one of my top records, ever. Yes, I did order the special edition as soon as they announced it, complete with my name in the back along with all of the other enslaved thousands that ordered it as well. It came in a beautifully bound, 200 page book replete with tourphotos and special edition DVD chronicling the making of the record. It even came with an actual strip of film from the video for Gobbledigook! I've got a naked lady on 16mm! Was it work the $100? Yes. And it's the most amount of money I've ever spent on a band, ever. Unless you count the $3000 on a guitar that I bought this year that was kinda influenced by hearing and seeing Ryan Adams', but that's only indirect. So i don't.
This record perfectly encapsulates the year for me. A year full of surprises, both good and bad, and being able to stay afloat no matter what came along. This band is the band of all bands. The number one on my top 5. That's why I know almost every word. Now if I can just see them live...
I suppose another thing I'm happy about as far as music goes this year is just how good the cover art has been this year. As i looked over my choices, I was sad that some wouldn't make it in because they just look so good together. Thank you, iTunes coverflow!
So that's it. That' s my list.
Merry New Year!
Hope 2009 turns out some equally wonderful tunes. Later!
Honorable mentions:
Underoath, Lost in the Sound of Separation. I'm not mad, guys, and I don't mean to poke. When the pendulum swung from the sing-along-sensibility of parts of
They're Only Chasing Safety to the raucous, purely metallic fury of
Define the Great Line, i was ecstatic. I only hoped the pendulum would keep on swinging. It didn't.
Death Cab for Cutie, Narrow Stairs. You took Zooey from us. Yer off the list! Really, this one was good- good enough for me to actually learn both the guitar and bass parts, but where it excels as being lesson fodder, it fails in being entirely memorable. I love the song "I Will Posess Your Heart", but I just can't take 4 minutes and 32 seconds of heady build-up. Killer bass line, just too long.
Weezer, Red Album. This one was better... It's no
Pinkerton.
Vampire Weekend, Vampire Weekend. I like it. I just don't adore it.
R.E.M., Accelerate. Slow it down, there, Chuck.
Sun Kil Moon, April. Just narrowly edged out by just how much i loved that Russian Red, someone had to be sacrificed and it was you. I loved it. Really, really great, though. Except in the context of a numerical list, i'd say this one was indispensable.
MGMT, MGMT. I know, i know, i just haven't given you enough of a chance. I'm gonna.
M.83, Saturdays = Youth- equal parts catchy and longwinded.
Noah and the Whale, Peaceful, the World Lays Me Down. Quirky and fun.
Foxy Shazam, Introducing Foxy Shazam. Foxy, oh Foxy. You're such a darling. A friend shoved this onto my harddrive declaring, "This will rock your ******* face off!" It's hardcore music, with all the screaming and buzzing riffs -but get this- it's piano driven. Interesting. Ultimately, a novelty listen. Still good.
Notes of interest:
If only Dethklok would put out a second.
And for those that may be concerned: I didn't yet get My Morning Jacket's latest, nor did I have a chance to get Portishead's
Third, or Elbow's
Seldom Seen Kid. I will, though.
And Mr. Tom Waits, I'm waiting as well. take your time, it will be worth it.